Walnut vs Maple Firewood: Which Burns Better

FirewoodGearHQ may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. The price you pay stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Walnut vs maple firewood: the difference

The listings checked for this guide stock two boxes: maple and oak. The maple box is the direct match for the maple side of the question, and the oak box is the closest alternative from the same Wilson line. Both are kiln dried and seasoned, both come in a 16 by 12 by 8 in box with splits from 1 to 3 in. The maple box is listed for the fireplace, fire pit and bonfire. No walnut box was in the listings, so this guide ranks the two stocked boxes and notes where each fits.

The two firewood boxes, ranked

First is the Wilson maple box: the keyword match. Kiln dried and seasoned maple for the fireplace, fire pit or bonfire, in the 16 by 12 by 8 in box with 1 to 3 in splits, sustainably harvested in the upper peninsula of Michigan. The listing notes that cooking with different wood species gives different aromas and adds a premium touch, and the box can double as a decorative filler for firewood racks before burning.

Second is the Wilson oak box: the same Wilson line in oak, kiln dried and seasoned, in the same 16 by 12 by 8 in box with 1 to 3 in splits, at 8.7 kg per the spec table. The listing suggests ordering multiple boxes for a longer lasting fire. It is the pick when the maple box is out of stock, or when you want to burn the two side by side and compare. See the oak vs maple firewood comparison for more on these two woods.

What kiln dried gets you

Both boxes go through a kiln dry process that the listing says wicks away moisture. The stated payoff is a hotter burn, less smoke and no smoldering, which is what you want whether the wood is maple or oak. Because the wood is already seasoned and kiln dried, what arrives in the box is ready to burn.

The splits run 1 to 3 in in diameter, which the listing describes as natural split and seasoned firewood. Because the wood is already seasoned and kiln dried, what arrives in the box is ready to burn, not wood that needs another season in the stack.

Getting the boxes home and stored

The Wilson boxes ship right to the doorstep, packed and easy to handle, which the listing calls out for locations that are difficult to reach with a truckload of cords. The 16 by 12 by 8 in box is packed and easy to handle, so it suits locations that are difficult to reach with a truckload of cords.

Before burning, the boxes can sit as decorative fillers in firewood racks and storage spaces, which keeps the wood handy and the hearth looking dressed. For a longer lasting fire, the listing suggests ordering multiple boxes, and the weight varies per box, so plan the order around how much you burn in a week.

Burn dry, store dry. Kiln dried wood stays ready only if it stays dry. Keep the boxes under cover and off damp floors until they go in the stove, and burn only seasoned wood for a cleaner fire with less smoke.

How to pick the right box

Start with the maple box if the question is walnut vs maple: it is the direct match for the maple side, kiln dried and seasoned for the fireplace, fire pit or bonfire. Pick the oak box when the maple is out of stock, or when you want to burn the two side by side and compare. Both come in the same 16 by 12 by 8 in box with 1 to 3 in splits, so the choice is about the wood, not the format. For a longer lasting fire, the listing suggests ordering multiple boxes, and the weight varies per box, so order based on how much you burn in a typical week rather than on a single box.

Getting the most from kiln-dried wood

Kiln-dried wood is ready to burn, but it stays ready only if it stays dry. Store the boxes under cover and off damp floors, and bring in only what the fire needs. The 1 to 3 in splits catch quickly, so build the fire with the smaller pieces first and add the larger splits once the coals are going. Because the wood is kiln dried, it lights with less kindling than green wood, which means less fuss on a cold evening. If the box doubles as a decorative filler for the firewood rack, keep it near the hearth so the wood is handy when the fire needs feeding.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the maple or the oak box better for the fireplace?

Both are kiln dried and seasoned. The maple box is the direct match for the maple side of the question and is listed for the fireplace, fire pit and bonfire; the oak box is the same line in oak. Pick by availability, or burn one of each and see which you prefer.

What size are the boxes?

Each box measures 16 by 12 by 8 in and holds natural split firewood from 1 to 3 in in diameter. The oak box lists 8.7 kg; the maple listing does not state a weight, and the listing notes weight varies per box.

Can I cook over this firewood?

The listings say cooking with different wood species achieves different aromas and adds a premium touch. Both boxes are listed as suitable for cooking use as well as heating.

Is the wood sustainably harvested?

The listings state the wood is sustainably harvested in the upper peninsula of Michigan. That claim covers both the maple and the oak boxes.

How many boxes should I order?

The listing suggests ordering multiple boxes for a longer lasting fire. Since the weight varies per box, plan the order around how much you burn in a week.

Related guides

See the oak vs maple firewood, the beech vs maple firewood, the birch vs maple firewood and the hickory vs maple firewood comparisons.