Propane Patio Heater vs Fire Pit: Which One Should You Buy?

FirewoodGearHQ may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. The price you pay stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Propane patio heater vs fire pit: the quick answer

A propane patio heater suits steady, adjustable warmth on a patio or deck. The listings here describe tower heaters with control knobs, wheels and coverage from a 9-foot radius to 20 feet in diameter or 200 sq. ft. A fire pit suits an open flame gathering spot and usually burns wood or a propane burner in a bowl or table. If you want heat you can dial up and down and move around the patio, the heater wins; if you want the look and ritual of an open flame, the fire pit wins.

How a propane patio heater differs from a fire pit

The heat arrives differently. A patio heater is a tall tower with a burner under a reflector cap: the listings describe radiant and convection heat spreading outward from a central spot, with a control knob to set the output. A wood fire pit is an open flame you sit around, with heat that falls off quickly as you move away and no dial to turn. The heater gives even, directed warmth; the fire pit gives atmosphere with heat as a bonus.

Fuel and setup differ too. The patio heaters here run on liquid propane: the Amazon Basics listing states a 20 pound liquid propane gas tank is required and not included, so plan on buying the tank separately. A fire pit burns split wood you feed by hand or a propane burner with its own tank. The heaters light with a one-touch or piezoelectric ignition and roll on wheels; a wood fire pit needs matches, kindling and tending. If your evenings already revolve around cutting and stacking firewood, a fire pit fits the routine; if you want heat at the push of a button, the heater fits better.

The gear: four propane patio heaters, ranked

Four propane patio heaters from the listings, ranked by heat output, coverage and stated safety features.

EAST OAK 50,000 BTU with table design

Tied for the highest stated output here at 50,000 BTU, and the only listing with a concrete warranty term. It states heat spreading up to 20 feet in diameter, with CSA and ETL certification stated. The double-layer 304 stainless steel burner mesh, conical barrel and triple protection system lead the safety story, and the round table design gives you a spot for drinks. A weight-adjustable water tank listed up to 26.45 lbs improves wind resistance, and the maker advises against use in storms or winds above force 6. The one-touch ignition lights the flame in less than five seconds. It measures 33″D x 18″W x 87″H, weighs 38.8 pounds and carries a 3 years warranty, the only concrete warranty term among the four.

Hykolity 50,000 BTU with sand box

Also 50,000 BTU, with a double-layer 304 stainless steel burner mesh and a sand box in the base. The listing states 200 sq. ft. of heating coverage, a table design, wheels and a tip-over protection system that extinguishes the flame if the heater tilts more than 45 degrees. The conical barrel comes with a weight-adjustable water tank listed up to 26.45 lbs for wind resistance. It measures 33.6″D x 33.6″W x 86.4″H and weighs 33 pounds. No warranty term is stated.

Hykolity 50,000 BTU with cover

A 50,000 BTU heater with a stainless steel burner, table design and wheels, covering a stated 200 sq. ft. The listing states triple protection with overheat protection, tip-over protection and a weather-resistant build, plus piezoelectric ignition and a multi-speed temperature adjustment. A cover is included in the box. The spec table lists 26″D x 18.1″W x 18.1″H, but 18.1 in of height does not match a tower heater, so treat that figure as a listing error. It weighs 32.5 pounds. The listing offers free exchange for quality problems within warranty, but states no warranty term.

Amazon Basics 46,000 BTU tower

The lowest output of the four at 46,000 BTU, covering a stated 9-foot radius. It has a tilt safety auto-shut off valve, a water box for weighing down the base, a wheel kit and a chain to secure the tank. The one-touch ignition button and adjustable temperature knob keep operation simple, and the powder-coated slate gray finish is built for outdoor use. The 20 pound liquid propane gas tank is required and not included. It measures 32.1″L x 32.1″W x 91.3″H and weighs 16.78 kg. No warranty term is stated.

Heat output and coverage

Three of the four heaters state 50,000 BTU; the Amazon Basics states 46,000 BTU. Coverage is stated three ways: the Amazon Basics covers a 9-foot radius, the EAST OAK spreads up to 20 feet in diameter, and both Hykolity heaters state 200 sq. ft. These are the makers’ figures for open patios, so a walled or windy spot will feel different. Match the coverage to your space: a small deck fits the 9-foot radius heater, while a large patio suits the 20-foot or 200 sq. ft. models.

Safety features the listings state

Every listing names safety features, and they are worth comparing. The Amazon Basics has a tilt safety auto-shut off valve, a water box for the base and a chain to secure the tank. The EAST OAK lists a triple protection system with CSA and ETL certification, plus a water tank for wind resistance. The Hykolity with cover lists triple protection with overheat protection, tip-over protection and a weather-resistant build. The Hykolity with sand box lists tip-over protection that kills the flame past 45 degrees of tilt. None of the listings state a UL listing for the heater itself. Use any patio heater on a stable, level surface and keep it clear of anything that can catch fire.

What to check before you buy

Check the tank situation first: the Amazon Basics listing states the 20 pound propane tank is not included, and the other three do not state a tank either way. All four list wheels, so moving them around the patio is part of the design. Assembly varies: the Hykolity with cover says setup takes less than an hour following the instructions, while the others state no assembly time. The EAST OAK has a round hole design in the bucket so you can close the gas valve without lifting it. On warranty, only the EAST OAK states a term: 3 years. The Hykolity with cover offers free exchange for quality problems within warranty with no term stated, and the other two state nothing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do these patio heaters include a propane tank?

The Amazon Basics listing states the 20 pound liquid propane gas tank is required and not included. The other three listings do not state a tank either way, so plan on supplying your own.

How much area does each heater cover?

The Amazon Basics states a 9-foot radius, the EAST OAK states up to 20 feet in diameter, and both Hykolity heaters state 200 sq. ft. These are the makers’ open-patio figures.

Which heater has a stated warranty?

The EAST OAK states a 3 years warranty. The Hykolity with cover offers free exchange for quality problems within warranty but states no term. The Amazon Basics and the Hykolity with sand box state no warranty.

Can I move these heaters around the patio?

Yes. All four listings state wheels: the Amazon Basics lists a wheel kit, the EAST OAK and both Hykolity heaters list wheels for moving the heater into place.

Are these heaters for indoor use?

All four spec tables list Outdoor use. The Hykolity with cover bullets mention indoor use, but its spec table says Outdoor, so follow the spec table and the maker’s guidance and keep them outside.

Related guides

See our tabletop vs freestanding patio heater and infrared vs convection patio heater comparisons. For fire pits, see the best propane fire pit for a deck and best smokeless fire pit under 200 picks, and compare wood burning fire pit vs outdoor wood heater.