Fire Pit Cover vs Fire Pit Screen: Which One Should You Buy?

FirewoodGearHQ may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. The price you pay stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

The quick answer

Buy a cover if your pit sits outside between uses and you want it protected from rain, snow, sun and dust. All three listings in this guide are covers: 600D and 900D polyester with waterproof coatings, vents, drawstrings, and buckle straps on two. Buy a screen if you burn wood and want a mesh barrier between the flames and the seating area while the fire is lit. A cover goes on after the fire is fully out and the pit is cool; a screen goes on while it burns. Neither replaces the other.

Fire pit cover vs fire pit screen: the cover

A cover is weather armor for an idle pit. The three listings here describe the same job: a waterproof fabric shell that keeps rain, snow, dust, leaves and bird droppings off the pit and out of the bowl. The Porch Shield uses 600D polyester with a waterproof undercoating and sealed seams; the ULTCOVER uses 600D polyester canvas with a waterproof backing; the QH.HOME uses 900D oxford fabric with a waterproof vinyl and PVC coating plus heat-sealed tape. All three add air vents to avoid condensation under the cover, and drawstrings or buckles to hold it in high wind.

Covers are sized to the pit, not the fire. The Porch Shield fits pits up to 42 in diameter and 24 in high; the ULTCOVER fits round pits up to 44 in; the QH.HOME fits 41 to 44 in diameter and 23 to 25 in high, and measures 44 by 44 by 24 in itself. Measure the pit before ordering, as the QH.HOME listing advises.

What a screen does

A screen is a mesh barrier that sits over or around the fire while it burns, catching sparks and embers before they reach people, furniture or dry leaves. None of the three listings in this guide is a screen, so compare screen listings on mesh fineness, frame sturdiness and how the screen opens for adding wood. A screen does not protect against weather, and it should come off when the fire is done so a cover can go on.

The covers in this guide

The QH.HOME cover leads on fabric denier. Its 900D oxford fabric is the highest denier here, with a waterproof vinyl and PVC coating, heat-sealed tape, UPF50+ sun protection fabric, vents, an adjustable drawstring, windproof buckles and a carry handle. The listing states no warranty term.

The Porch Shield 600D cover is the warranty pick. It pairs 600D polyester with a waterproof undercoating, UV resistant treatment, double-stitched sealed seams, an adjustable elastic hem cord, bottom buckle straps, air vents and ribbon handles, and states a 3 years warranty. It fits pits up to 42 in diameter and 24 in high.

The ULTCOVER 600D cover is the straightforward option. It fits round pits up to 44 in, with 600D polyester canvas, a waterproof backing, structured air vents, plastic clips and heavy duty elastic draw cords, and states a 3 Year Warranty. The listing names no buckle straps, unlike the other two.

Fit and fabric: what the listings state

Fit first, fabric second. All three covers are round and sized by diameter: 42 in for the Porch Shield, 44 in for the ULTCOVER, 41 to 44 in for the QH.HOME. A cover that is too small will not fit the pit; one that is too large flaps in the wind. All three listings state drawstrings, and two add buckle straps.

On fabric, the listings agree on polyester with a waterproof layer and UV treatment, differing on denier: 600D on two, 900D on the QH.HOME. All three are waterproof rated, and all three include vents. The Porch Shield and ULTCOVER state 3-year warranties; the QH.HOME states none.

The covers are light enough for one person: the Porch Shield lists 1.41 kg and the QH.HOME 1.1 kg. Colors are black for the Porch Shield, brown for the ULTCOVER and wheat for the QH.HOME, all with UV or fade-resistant treatment. The Porch Shield listing names the fire pit brands it fits, including Fire Sense, Hampton Bay, Bali Outdoors and Yaheetech, which helps if you own one of those tables.

Attachments and extras

How the cover stays on matters as much as fit. The Porch Shield uses an adjustable elastic hem cord plus bottom buckle straps, with heavy duty ribbon handles woven into the air vents for pulling the cover on and off. The ULTCOVER uses plastic clips and heavy duty elastic draw cords that secure to the fire table legs, aimed at high winds and severe weather. The QH.HOME pairs an adjustable drawstring with windproof buckles and adds a portable carry handle.

The QH.HOME listing claims its 900D fabric beats traditional 210D, 420D and 600D materials on tear resistance, and says the cover uses original color yarn rather than post-dyed fabric for fade resistance. The Porch Shield listing describes ripstop construction with double-stitched sealed seams, and offers a quick-fix replacement process for product issues or shipping damage.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a fire pit cover go on while the fire is burning?

No. Covers are polyester fabric shells for weather protection, and the listings describe them for idle pits. Let the fire burn fully out and the pit cool before covering.

Does a screen protect the pit from rain?

No. A screen is an open mesh for spark control while burning. Weather protection is the cover’s job; the three listings here all describe waterproof covers for idle pits.

What size cover do I need?

Measure the pit’s diameter and height, then match a listing. The Porch Shield fits up to 42 in diameter and 24 in high, the ULTCOVER up to 44 in, and the QH.HOME 41 to 44 in diameter and 23 to 25 in high.

Do I need both a cover and a screen?

If the pit lives outdoors and you burn wood, yes. The screen works while the fire burns; the cover works between fires. The listings in this guide cover only the cover side.

Which cover has a warranty?

The Porch Shield states a 3 years warranty and the ULTCOVER a 3 Year Warranty. The QH.HOME listing states no warranty term.

Related guides

See the stove accessories section, the best fire pit cover for winter and best fire pit cover for rainy climates guides, and the best fire pit screen for a patio guide for the screen side.