Electric Fire Starter vs Fire Starter Sticks: Which Should You Buy?

FirewoodGearHQ may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. The price you pay stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Electric fire starter vs fire starter sticks: the quick answer

For lighting a wood stove or fireplace every day, an electric arc lighter wins on convenience: USB rechargeable, windproof plasma arc, no fuel to buy and no flame to blow out. For camping, emergencies and backup, a magnesium firestarter kit wins on independence: no battery, no charging, waterproof and good for hundreds of uses per the maker. Utility lighters sit between them: instant flame in a 4-pack, but the fuel runs out. One honest note on the listings here: none of the four is literally a fire starter stick, so the stick side of this guide is represented by the closest flame and spark options, and the comparison stays with what the listings actually state.

Electric fire starters: how they work

An electric fire starter is an arc lighter: pressing the switch draws a plasma arc across two electrodes, and that arc lights paper, kindling shavings or a wax starter directly. No fuel, no flame, nothing to refill. The SUPRUS example adds a safety lock you push before the ignition switch, an automatic power-off chip and a spark that auto-stops beyond 7 seconds per ignition, plus 4 LED lights on the barrel that show the battery level. The LcFun example is a dual arc lighter with a waterproof IP56 rating, a metal-ring sealed cover with a locking clasp and a paracord lanyard, charging to full in about 1 hour over USB with no gas or butane.

The trade is the battery. An arc lighter that is dead when you need it is a paperweight, so it suits the house, where a USB port is always nearby, better than the deep woods. Both electric examples here are small: the SUPRUS at 7.56 by 0.49 by 0.61 in and 0.05 kg, the LcFun at 2.7 by 0.47 by 1.87 in and 1.55 oz. Neither lists a per-charge ignition count, so the listings leave that unclear.

Flame and spark starters: how they work

The other side is fire you can hold. The Click-n-Flame 4-pack gives four long-stem utility lighters with a flexible shaft for reaching into grills, fireplaces and candle jars, running on liquefied petroleum gas with a push-button trigger. Instant flame, no learning curve, and four of them means one for the kitchen, one for the fireplace and spares. The SE FS374 is the opposite philosophy: a 3 by 1 in magnesium bar with a flint and a serrated striker on a detachable chain, waterproof and weatherproof, with the maker claiming hundreds of uses from the solid magnesium fuel bar. Shave magnesium, strike the flint, catch a spark.

One listing needs a flag: the SE spec table’s Description field describes a stainless steel spoon, fork and knife set, which has nothing to do with a firestarter. That is a copy error in the listing; trust the title and bullets, which describe the magnesium bar, flint and striker. The spec table also lists a 90 day woot limited warranty, which is the only warranty term among the four.

Side by side

	Electric arc lighter	Utility lighter	Magnesium kit
Ignition	Plasma arc, flameless	Gas flame	Spark from flint on magnesium
Fuel	None; USB rechargeable	Liquefied petroleum gas	Magnesium bar, hundreds of uses stated
Wind	Windproof arc stated (both)	Wind resistant stated	Waterproof and weatherproof stated
Size and weight	2.7 to 7.56 in long; 0.05 kg / 1.55 oz	4-pack; 12 oz listed	3 x 1 in; 12 oz listed
Safety extras	Safety lock, auto power-off, 7-second spark limit (SUPRUS)	Long flexible shaft keeps hands back	Detachable chain; nothing electronic
Warranty or service	24h friendly services (SUPRUS); 60-day service promise (LcFun)	Not stated	90 day limited warranty stated

The table uses only stated figures. The two 12 oz weights come from spec tables and read as package weights; treat them as listed, not measured.

The gear: four starters ranked

1. LcFun dual arc plasma lighter. The outdoor electric pick: dual arc, IP56 waterproof with a sealed cover and locking clasp, about 1 hour to full charge over USB, no gas or butane, with a paracord lanyard and zinc alloy build at 1.55 oz. The maker offers a 60-day service promise. It is the electric starter most at home in a camp kit.

2. SUPRUS electric arc lighter. The hearth pick: windproof flameless plasma arc with a safety lock, automatic power-off chip, a 7-second per-ignition spark limit and 4 LEDs showing real-time battery level. At 7.56 in long it reaches into a fireplace like a long match that never burns down. USB cable, gift box and manual in the box, with 24-hour friendly service stated.

3. SE magnesium firestarter kit. The no-battery backup: a 3 by 1 in solid magnesium bar with flint and a single-sided serrated striker on a detachable chain, waterproof and weatherproof, with hundreds of uses claimed. It works wet, works cold and never needs charging, which is exactly what an emergency kit wants. The only stated warranty of the four at 90 days, and the spec table’s cutlery description is a listing error to ignore.

4. Click-n-Flame 4-pack utility lighters. The convenience pick: four wind-resistant LPG lighters with flexible shafts and push-button triggers for BBQ, fireplace, candles and camp stoves. Instant flame with zero learning curve, and four units cover several rooms. It ranks last here only because fuel runs out and there is no refill or recharge path stated; as a pure lighter it does its job.

Which should you buy

Buy the electric arc lighter if you light a stove or fireplace daily and want the quickest no-fuss ignition with no fuel to buy: the SUPRUS for the hearth, the LcFun if the kit also goes outdoors. Buy the magnesium kit if you want a backup that cannot die: no battery, no fuel, waterproof, hundreds of uses. Buy the utility 4-pack if you want instant flame in several places at once and accept replacing them. Many households end up with two: an arc lighter by the stove and a magnesium kit in the emergency bag, which covers both the daily chore and the bad day.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an electric arc lighter safe to use?

The SUPRUS listing describes a safety lock, an automatic power-off chip and a spark that stops beyond 7 seconds per ignition, all aimed at safe handling. Like any ignition source, keep it away from children and flammable vapors, and follow the manual that comes in the box.

Will an arc lighter work in the wind?

That is its headline advantage: both electric listings state a windproof flameless arc that strong winds cannot blow out the way they can a flame. The LcFun adds an IP56 waterproof rating for rainy days.

How long does an electric lighter hold a charge?

The listings do not state a per-charge ignition count. The LcFun charges to full in about 1 hour over USB, and the SUPRUS shows battery level on 4 LEDs. For daily stove use, topping up regularly is the practical habit.

What is better for emergencies, arc or magnesium?

Magnesium, for independence: the SE kit needs no battery, no charging and no fuel, works waterproof and claims hundreds of uses. An arc lighter is better for daily convenience but useless with a dead battery, so the emergency bag wants the magnesium kit.

Are utility lighters enough for a wood stove?

They light kindling and starters fine, and the Click-n-Flame’s long flexible shaft keeps hands back from the firebox. Their limit is fuel: a 4-pack gives spares, but each lighter is disposable once empty, with no refill path stated.

Do I still need fire starter sticks with an arc lighter?

Often, yes. The arc lights tinder, but a stove still wants kindling and a starter to catch reliably, especially with damp wood. See our best fire starter for damp wood and fatwood vs fire starter cubes comparisons.

Related guides

See the best fire starter for a cold stove, the fire starter vs kindling comparison, our best splitting axe for kindling and the cheap fire starters roundup.