Copper vs Galvanized Chimney Cap: Which Should You Buy?

FirewoodGearHQ may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. The price you pay stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Copper vs galvanized chimney cap: the short answer

Galvanized steel wins on availability and value. All three caps below are galvanized, they fit the standard masonry flue tiles the listings describe, and one of them carries a 7-year limited warranty. Copper is the premium-material alternative: the HY-C Draft King CBO2020 lists copper among its available materials, so if you want copper you can get the same cap design in that metal. Stainless steel is the third material HY-C lists. If the budget allows the upgrade and you like the look, buy the copper version of the HY-C; otherwise buy galvanized and spend the difference on wood.

What galvanized steel gets you

The two CLLOMAGY caps state 14-gauge galvanized steel bases and 24-gauge galvanized steel hoods, which the listings call sturdy, robust, corrosion and heat resistant. Both claim to stand up to strong wind, rain and snow without deformation, and both spec tables check off rustproof and rainproof. The mesh screen keeps out small animals, birds, rain, snow, leaves and some downward drafts. That is a lot of stated protection from a plain galvanized cap, and it explains why galvanized dominates the lineup.

The HY-C Draft King CBO2020 is the heavier-duty galvanized pick. It pairs a 24-gauge powder-coated galvanized steel hood with scalloped corners and roll-formed edges against an 18-gauge base and a 3/4 inch 100 percent galvanized steel expanded metal mesh. Outside mounting gives greater free air space, and the mesh is turned inward at the base so the cover rests firmly on the flue tile with no gaps for wildlife. It is made in the USA and carries a 7 year limited warranty, the longest stated term of the three.

What copper gets you

Honesty first: this lineup contains no all-copper cap, only the HY-C spec table naming copper among the materials the CBO2020 design is available in. So treat copper as an upgrade path, not a competing pick. The design itself is identical: same 20 by 20 inch footprint, same bolt-on outside mount, same mesh construction. What changes is the metal. If you want the copper look, order the copper version of the HY-C from the materials the listing names: black galvanized steel, stainless steel and copper.

Sizing and fit

Measure the outside of your flue tile before ordering. The CLLOMAGY 18×18 cap covers outside flue tiles from 16 1/2 by 16 1/2 inches to 18 1/2 by 18 1/2 inches. The CLLOMAGY 13×18 covers 11 1/2 by 16 1/2 inches to 13 1/2 by 18 1/2 inches. The HY-C Draft King fits outside tile dimensions from 18.5 by 18.5 inches to 20.25 by 20.25 inches. All three suit masonry chimneys with brick, clay, terra cotta or masonry flue tiles; the HY-C states it is not suitable for metal chimneys.

A note on the listings: both CLLOMAGY spec tables say “Size: 9X9 inch” while the titles and bullets say 18×18 and 13×18. Per our rule of trusting the title and bullets over the spec table, treat the title sizes as correct and the 9X9 figure as a listing error.

The gear: three galvanized caps ranked

1. HY-C Draft King CBO2020. The top pick: 20 by 20 inches, powder-coated galvanized hood, 18-gauge mesh, outside bolt-on mount, made in the USA, and a 7 year limited warranty. It is also the only cap here with a stated copper option, which makes it the answer to the copper side of this guide.

2. CLLOMAGY 18×18. A 14-gauge base and 24-gauge hood at a listed 12.72 pounds, with a mesh screen and slide-on mounting that needs no drilling. It covers the common 16 1/2 to 18 1/2 inch flue tiles. No warranty term is stated.

3. CLLOMAGY 13×18. Same 14-gauge base and 24-gauge hood in a rectangular 13×18 size for 11 1/2 by 16 1/2 to 13 1/2 by 18 1/2 inch tiles, at a listed 10.08 pounds. Same slide-on mounting, and likewise no warranty term stated.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a copper chimney cap better than galvanized?

For most masonry chimneys, galvanized is the practical answer: the CLLOMAGY listings here state 14-gauge bases and 24-gauge hoods, and the listings state rustproof, rainproof construction. Copper is the premium-material alternative, available on the HY-C Draft King design alongside stainless steel.

Will a galvanized cap rust?

Both CLLOMAGY spec tables check off rustproof, and the HY-C uses powder-coated galvanized steel. The listings present galvanized as corrosion resistant for harsh outdoor weather, but no listing here states a corrosion warranty, so keep expectations to what is printed.

What size cap do I need?

Measure the outside of the flue tile. The picks cover 11 1/2 by 16 1/2 inches up to 20.25 by 20.25 inches across the three listings, so match your tile to the fitment ranges above before ordering.

Can I install a chimney cap myself?

These listings describe slide-on or bolt-on mounting with pre-drilled holes and no drilling. We do not publish installation steps: for anything beyond the listing description, have a certified chimney professional handle the work. Pair the cap with a chimney brush for a masonry chimney for routine cleaning.

Do I need a cap for a metal chimney?

The HY-C Draft King states it is not suitable for metal chimneys. Check the best chimney cap for a metal roof guide for metal-chimney options, and the best chimney cap for masonry chimney roundup for more masonry picks.

Related guides

See the stove accessories hub, the best chimney cap for masonry chimney roundup and the best chimney brush for a masonry chimney guide.