Small vs Large Fire Pit: Which One Should You Buy? (2026)

FirewoodGearHQ may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. The price you pay stays the same. Affiliate disclosure.

Small vs large fire pit: the quick answer

Size the pit to the gathering, not the yard. The Sunnydaze 36 in example seats 6 to 8 people around a 31 in fire bowl; the Amazon Basics 27 in example is the mid-size backyard pit. The HGD 5.5 in and AmazStove 9.7 in examples are tabletop pits for s’mores and ambiance, not for heating a patio. A large pit burns wood and wants a permanent spot: the Sunnydaze listing calls for stone, brick, gravel or a fire-safe pad. A small pit burns pellets or small wood pieces and goes back in its bag. If you are choosing between them, count the chairs first.

What a large fire pit gives you

A large fire pit is a group appliance. The Sunnydaze example measures 36 in across with a 31 in fire bowl 11 in deep, seats 6 to 8, and weighs 23.8 lb; the Amazon Basics example measures 27.4 in across at 17.6 lb. Both burn wood, as their listings state, both include a spark screen and a poker, and the Sunnydaze adds a cover. A large bowl takes far more wood per load than a tabletop, so more chairs can gather around it. The trade is commitment: the Sunnydaze spans 36 in across and the Amazon Basics 27.4 in, and both want a permanent spot in the yard; the Sunnydaze listing says to place it on stone, brick, gravel or a fire-safe pad, not directly on a deck.

What a small fire pit gives you

A small fire pit is a portable accent. The HGD example measures 5.5 in across at 1.7 lb with a carry bag; the AmazStove example measures 7.1 in across at 2.8 lb with a travel bag. The HGD claims a double-wall smokeless design, and the AmazStove a dual 360 updraft burn with low smoke; the AmazStove listing claims 50 to 60 minutes of burn from up to 2.5 lb of pellets or 8 in wood pieces. Do not buy a tabletop pit to heat a patio or cook for a crowd: it makes a centerpiece flame for two or three people, roasts marshmallows, and packs away. The trade is capacity: small fuel, and the AmazStove is the only one here to state a burn time.

Heat: what each size actually throws

The listings state no BTU or heat-radius figures, so read the dimensions instead. A 31 in fire bowl holds a real wood fire with room for airflow; a 5.5 in bowl holds a handful of pellets. Heat follows fire size: the large pits warm a seating circle, the small pits warm hands. The Sunnydaze listing describes its crossweave cutouts pulling air from below for a hotter burn with less smoke; the HGD listing describes a double-wall design for reduced smoke, and the AmazStove a dual 360 updraft burn for low smoke. None of this changes the physics: a tabletop pit is ambiance, not heating.

Fuel and feeding

Large pits burn wood, as both listings state. The Sunnydaze bowl is 11 in deep with a log grate; the Amazon Basics listing names wood fuel without a bowl depth. Small pits burn what fits: the AmazStove takes 8 in wood pieces or up to 2.5 lb of pellets for a 50 to 60 minute burn, per the listing. The HGD lists wood and pellets without quantities. A large pit wants a wood supply and a place to stack it; a small pit wants a bag of pellets from the store. Match the pit to the fuel you will actually buy.

Where it sits and how it stores

A large pit needs a permanent home: stone, brick, gravel or a fire-safe pad, per the Sunnydaze listing, with the cover on between uses. At 23.8 and 17.6 lb the large examples move around the yard by hand; the Sunnydaze listing even names camping trips and lakeside retreats as uses, so treat them as car-camping portable, not backpacking portable. A small pit goes where the evening goes: the HGD at 1.7 lb and the AmazStove at 2.8 lb pack into their bags for camping, picnics and balconies. Storage is the small pit’s whole argument: it disappears into a closet, while the large pit owns its corner of the yard year-round.

Safety gear by size

Both large examples ship a spark screen and a poker: the Sunnydaze screen sits on top at 24 in overall height, and the poker doubles as the screen lifter. Neither small example lists a spark screen; only the large examples ship one. The safety rule does not scale down, though: every pit here burns wood, so the standard clearances from structures apply to all four. The Sunnydaze listing is the only one to state placement surfaces explicitly.

The gear: four examples, ranked

Sunnydaze 36 in Crossweave. The large-group pick: 36 in across, 31 in fire bowl, seats 6 to 8, with spark screen, poker and cover in the box and a 1-year limited warranty. At 23.8 lb one person can carry it by the outer ring. The bowl has no drainage holes, so the listing says to empty rainwater and cover it after each use.

Amazon Basics 27 in Lattice. The mid-size pick: 27.4 in across, 23 in fire bowl, with spark screen and poker, at 17.6 lb and a 1-year limited warranty. Less pit than the Sunnydaze for smaller yards and smaller groups, with the same basic kit.

AmazStove 9.7 in Tabletop. The small-pit pick with the most stated: 304 stainless steel, low-smoke burn, 50 to 60 minutes from 2.5 lb of pellets or 8 in wood, travel bag included, and a 3-years service promise. At 2.8 lb it is the most capable tabletop here on paper.

HGD 5.5 in Tabletop. The smallest pick: 5.5 in across at 1.7 lb, double-wall smokeless design, removable ash grate and carry bag. The listing states no warranty and no burn time, which puts it last among the small pits despite the portability.

Frequently Asked Questions

What size fire pit do I need?

Count the chairs. Six to eight people want a 31 in bowl like the Sunnydaze example; two or three around a table want a tabletop like the AmazStove or HGD examples. The 27 in Amazon Basics sits between.

Can a tabletop fire pit heat a patio?

No. The AmazStove is the only one here to state a burn time: 50 to 60 minutes on pellets or 8 in wood pieces. These are ambiance and marshmallows, not patio heating.

Do small fire pits need a spark screen?

Neither small example lists one, while both large examples ship spark screens. Treat every open flame the same way: standard clearances still apply.

Where should a large fire pit sit?

The Sunnydaze listing says stone, brick, gravel or a fire-safe pad, not directly on a deck. A large pit is a permanent installation; pick the spot before you buy.

Which of these state a warranty?

The Sunnydaze and Amazon Basics state 1-year limited warranties, and the AmazStove promises 3-years service. The HGD listing states no warranty.

Related guides

• Best Smokeless Fire Pit for Patio (2026): 5 Compared
• Best Fire Pit for Deck (2026): 5 Picks Compared
• Best Fire Pit with Lid (2026)
• Wood Stove vs Fire Pit: Which One Should You Buy?
• Outdoor Wood Rack for Fire Pit: 5 Metal Holders Compared (2026)

See our best smokeless fire pit for patio and best fire pit for deck picks, plus the wood stoves hub.