Leather vs Synthetic Chainsaw Gloves: Which One Should You Buy?

FirewoodGearHQ may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. The price you pay stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Leather vs synthetic chainsaw gloves: the short answer

Pick leather for hauling, bucking and wood stove work: the WZQH listings state 100% split cowhide with a cotton lining, reinforced palms and heat resistance, which suits hot and rough tasks. Pick synthetic for dexterity and easy care: the HANDLANDY and Schwer gloves machine wash and keep touch screens usable. For the cut-resistance end, the Schwer ProGuard states an ANSI A9 cut rating, the highest stated rating here.

What the listings tell you

Two leather: the WZQH gloves in X-Small and Small, both 100% split cowhide with soft cotton fiber lining, reinforced palms and adjustable wrists. Two synthetic: the HANDLANDY in polyester blend and spandex with a synthetic leather padded palm, and the Schwer ProGuard in HPPE, polyester, spandex and metal wire with a sandy nitrile coated palm. Sizes: XS and S on the WZQH pair, L on the HANDLANDY and the Schwer. Weights: 5.28 ounces on the WZQH XS, 6.08 ounces on the WZQH S, 80 g on the HANDLANDY; the Schwer states no weight.

Ratings: what is stated

The Schwer ProGuard states an ANSI A9 cut rating with a reinforced thumb, the top-tier cut claim here, plus sandy nitrile coating the listing says gives grip in wet and greasy conditions. The WZQH Small states ANSI ISEA Heat Level 4; the WZQH XS states no ANSI level. The HANDLANDY states ANSI ISEA Impact Level 2 with foam-padded vibration dampening. The WZQH listings claim cut, abrasion, puncture, thorn and flame resistance in their feature text, but only the Small states an ANSI level. For actual cut protection, the A9-rated Schwer is the stated pick.

Care and warranties

The HANDLANDY and Schwer state machine wash; the WZQH XS says wipe clean with a damp cloth and hang to dry, no machine wash or dry. Warranties: the Schwer states a limited lifetime warranty with a 30-day satisfaction window; the HANDLANDY states a warranty description for material or craftsmanship defects within 90; the WZQH listings state a satisfaction guarantee with no stated term. Synthetic wins on stated care: both synthetics machine wash.

The gear: four gloves, ranked

1. Schwer ProGuard. The protection pick: ANSI A9 cut rating, sandy nitrile palm, reinforced thumb, touchscreen compatibility, breathable 13-gauge knit, machine washable, and the strongest stated warranty term here (limited lifetime with a 30-day window). The synthetic to beat.

2. WZQH leather, Small. The leather pick: 100% split cowhide, cotton lining, reinforced palm, adjustable wrist, and the only leather listing with a stated ANSI level (heat level 4). The listing names chainsaw use directly.

3. HANDLANDY. The dexterity pick: polyester blend and spandex with a padded synthetic leather palm, ANSI ISEA impact level 2, foam-padded vibration dampening, touchscreen use, machine washable. The light-duty synthetic.

4. WZQH leather, X-Small. Same leather build as the Small at 5.28 ounces, but in X-Small with no stated ANSI level and wipe-clean-only care. Ranks last on stated ratings.

Fit, sizing and closure

Sizes: X-Small and Small on the WZQH leather pair, Large on the HANDLANDY and the Schwer. The WZQH listings state an adjustable wrist that keeps debris out and come in six sizes from XSmall to 2XLarge in the product family. The HANDLANDY states a hook and loop closure with a regular fit and a reinforced thumb. The Schwer is a pull-on glove with a one-size-fits-all fit type and a reinforced thumb crotch. All four state ambidextrous hand orientation. Fit matters for chainsaw work: a loose glove is a handling hazard, so match the stated size to your hand before buying.

Materials and construction detail

The WZQH listings state 100% split cowhide leather with a soft cotton fiber lining, reinforced palms, cut-and-sewn construction with reinforced stitching, and no stretch. The HANDLANDY states a polyester blend and spandex back with a synthetic leather padded palm, foam-padded vibration dampening, double stitching and medium stretch. The Schwer states a 13-gauge knit of HPPE, polyester, spandex and metal wire with a sandy nitrile coated palm, knitted dipped construction and medium stretch. The WZQH Small adds a keystone thumb; the Schwer a bracelet sleeve. For rough hauling, the heavyweight leather build suits; for dexterity, the lightweight knit synthetics suit.

Reusability and water resistance

All four listings state reusable gloves. None states water resistance: the WZQH listings state not water resistant and waterproof false, and the HANDLANDY and Schwer state not water resistant as well. The WZQH XS care instructions say wipe clean with a damp cloth and hang to dry, with no machine wash or dry; the WZQH Small states machine wash in its spec table. The HANDLANDY and Schwer state machine wash. For wet firewood work, none of these is the waterproof pick; for dirty work, the machine-washable synthetics are the easier keep.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these chainsaw protective gloves?

No. None of the four listings claims chainsaw cut protection. They are work gloves suited to chainsaw work; the Schwer ProGuard states an ANSI A9 cut rating, which is cut resistance, not chainsaw chain protection.

Which leather glove is better?

The Small states ANSI ISEA heat level 4; the X-Small states no ANSI level. Both state 100% split cowhide with cotton lining and reinforced palms. Size decides the rest: XS against S.

Which synthetic glove for cut work?

The Schwer ProGuard with its stated ANSI A9 rating and sandy nitrile palm. The HANDLANDY is the lighter mechanic-style glove with impact level 2.

Can I machine wash them?

The HANDLANDY and Schwer state machine wash. The WZQH XS says wipe clean with a damp cloth and hang to dry; do not machine wash or dry.

Which gloves keep touch screens working?

The HANDLANDY states touchscreen use and the Schwer states touchscreen compatibility. The leather WZQH listings state no touchscreen feature.

Related: best chainsaw gloves for women, fireplace gloves vs welding gloves,.