Best 24 Inch Fireplace Grate (2026): 5 Sturdy Picks

Compare the picks

Specifications are manufacturer rated, collected 22 October 2026. None of these listings states a warranty term with a length, and none names a safety standard, so all five score zero on warranty and safety.

How we scored them

Each grate is scored on performance, build, value, safety and warranty, with the weights published on our How We Pick page. The stainless BeneLabel leads on material, the Pleasant Hearth 6-bar on bar thickness, and the jkxoo on bar count. With no warranty term or safety standard stated on any listing, those two criteria score zero across the board.

Scores run from 9.2 to 9.8: each product’s point total is placed on that range, so more points always means a higher score. Safety counts only for powered gear or where the listing states safety features; where it does not apply, the score is taken over the remaining 90 points.

Buying guide: best 24 inch fireplace grate

Bar count and thickness

Bars run 5 to 7 across the listings that state a count: 5 on the Pleasant Hearth 5-bar, 6 on the Pleasant Hearth 6-bar, 7 on the jkxoo. Thickness runs 1/2 in to 3/4 in: the Pleasant Hearth 6-bar lists 3/4 in solid bars, the thickest stated, while the Pleasant Hearth 5-bar and G GOOD GAIN list 1/2 in. Thicker bars and more of them read as longer grate life, and the 21.1 lbs Pleasant Hearth 6-bar is the heaviest of the five.

Steel, stainless or cast iron

The BeneLabel lists SUS304 stainless steel, stated as rust-proof and corrosion-resistant, the best material story here. The Pleasant Hearth grates and the jkxoo list steel; the jkxoo spec table says iron while its title and bullets say solid round steel, so the bullets win. The G GOOD GAIN bullets say Q235 steel while its spec table says cast iron; again the bullets win. When a listing contradicts itself, trust the title and bullets over the spec table. For rust, the BeneLabel stainless is the only listing that claims rust-proof outright; the others rely on powder-coated, painted or high-temperature finishes.

Legs and stability

Legs run 4 to 6 on the listings that state a count: the jkxoo lists four thick feet plus two middle feet against sagging, and the G GOOD GAIN adds 2 extra support legs in the middle. The other three do not state a leg count. More legs and a V-shaped frame read as better resistance to sagging under a full load of logs, and the jkxoo V-frame is the most explicit stability story here.

Ember retainers

Two listings state an ember retainer: the Pleasant Hearth 5-bar, which says it helps keep the fire hotter and burn more efficiently, and the G GOOD GAIN, which says the retainer makes for a cleaner and more efficient fire as all wood is burned. The other three state no retainer. If embers spilling forward is the problem, pick a retainer model.

Size and fit

All five are 24 in wide. Depths run 11.53 to 15 in and heights 3.5 to 7.5 in on the listings that state them, so measure the firebox before buying. The G GOOD GAIN bullets measure 24 x 14.5 x 3.5 in against its spec table’s 7.5 in height; the bullets win. The jkxoo notes 17, 21, 27 and 30 in sizes for other fireboxes.

Around the Woodpile

• All five grates are 24 in wide; measure the firebox depth and height before buying.
• None of the listings states a warranty term or a safety standard; buy on the stated specs.
• The BeneLabel is the only stainless grate here; the rest are steel with powder-coated or painted finishes.
• Ember retainers are stated on two of the five; the others rely on bar spacing to hold the fire.

Frequently Asked Questions

What size grate fits my fireplace?

Measure the firebox first. All five grates here are 24 in wide; depths run 11.53 to 15 in and heights 3.5 to 7.5 in on the listings that state them. The jkxoo also lists 17, 21, 27 and 30 in sizes. A grate that fits with room to spare beats one wedged tight.

Steel, stainless or cast iron?

The BeneLabel lists SUS304 stainless steel, rust-proof and corrosion-resistant. The rest list steel, except the G GOOD GAIN spec table, which says cast iron against its bullets’ Q235 steel; the bullets win. Stainless is the best corrosion story stated here.

Do I need an ember retainer?

Two of the five state one: the Pleasant Hearth 5-bar and the G GOOD GAIN. The listings say the retainer keeps embers contained and helps the fire burn hotter and more efficiently. If embers spilling forward is the problem, pick a retainer model.

How high should the grate lift the wood?

The listings describe lifting wood off the fireplace floor so air circulates underneath. The G GOOD GAIN keeps wood over 2 in off the ground; the BeneLabel bullets give two different heights, 6 1/2 in and 4 1/3 in, so treat its lift as unclear.

Can these go in an outdoor fire pit?

Three listings state indoor and outdoor use: the G GOOD GAIN, the jkxoo and the BeneLabel. The two Pleasant Hearth listings describe fireplace use. Follow the listing for the grate you buy, and keep a powder-coated grate out of standing water regardless of the use claim.

Related guides

See the best fireplace grate for a stone fireplace picks, the mesh vs glass fireplace screen comparison, the fireplace gloves vs oven mitts comparison and the best fireplace lighter picks.