Makita vs Milwaukee Chainsaw: Which One Should You Buy?

Makita vs Milwaukee chainsaw, side by side

Example figures are manufacturer rated, collected 21 October 2026. A figure from one listing describes that listing only.

Power: volts and amp-hours

Both Makita examples run 36V from two 18V LXT batteries, with 5.0Ah batteries in the kits; the XCU04PT1 ships four of them. Both claim power equivalent to a 32cc gas saw, the maker’s claim. The Milwaukee example is battery powered with no amp-hours stated, so the two sides cannot be compared on capacity.

Bar and chain speed

All three examples state a 16 in bar. Only the Makita side states chain speed: 3,940 FPM on the XCU04PT and 0 to 3,940 FPM on the XCU04PT1, with a variable speed trigger on both. The Milwaukee listing states no chain speed, which is a gap, not a loss.

Safety features

The Makita XCU04PT states a lock-off lever that helps prevent accidental engagement and an LED on/off switch with auto power-off. The XCU04PT1 and the Milwaukee state no chain brake, no low-kickback chain and no safety certification. On a real saw, chaps, a helmet with face screen and hearing protection, gloves and boots are the baseline, and nobody should cut alone.

Warranty

Both Makita examples state a 3-year limited warranty on tool, battery and charger. The Milwaukee states a 5 yr warranty on material and workmanship, the longest term of the three, which is its clearest edge.

Makita vs Milwaukee chainsaw: what to weigh before you buy

The listings state the real differences. Below is buying advice built only from what the three examples publish, so you can tell a stated fact from a gap.

Start with the battery platform you already own

Both Makita examples run 36V from two 18V LXT batteries. If you already own Makita 18V LXT tools, the XCU04PT1 kit ships four 5.0Ah batteries, so the saw slots straight into the fleet you charge every night. The Milwaukee example is battery powered but states no amp-hours, no volts and no platform name, so a Milwaukee loyalist should confirm the listing matches their existing batteries before buying. Batteries are the long-term cost of a battery saw: the listing that states its batteries clearly lets you plan, and the one that does not leaves you guessing.

Four batteries versus two: runtime planning

The Makita XCU04PT1 ships four 5.0Ah batteries, while the Makita XCU04PT kit lists 5.0Ah batteries without stating a count, so compare by the kit description when you shop. With two batteries slotted in the saw, a four-battery kit leaves a second pair charging while you cut, which is how long bucking sessions keep moving. If you only clear storm limbs now and then, the smaller kit may be enough. Either way, store and charge the batteries per the listing: the Makita 3-year limited warranty covers tool, battery and charger together, so a battery failure inside three years is a warranty claim, not a rebuy.

Read the bar and chain speed as a pair

All three examples state a 16 in bar, so bar length does not separate them. Chain speed does: the Makita XCU04PT states 3,940 FPM and the XCU04PT1 states 0 to 3,940 FPM with a variable speed trigger, which lets you feather the cut through knots and small limbs. The Milwaukee states no chain speed, so do not assume it runs faster or slower. Both Makita listings also state tool-less chain adjustment, which matters because a new chain stretches: re-tensioning at the woodpile without digging out a wrench keeps the work moving.

Weight, size and the numbers that look odd

The Makita XCU04PT lists a 19.2 lb kit weight and dimensions of 21.9 in L x 10.2 in W x 10.2 in H. The Milwaukee lists 36 in L x 10 in W x 11 in H, a length that reads like a shipping box rather than the saw itself, and the Milwaukee listing states no weight at all. If the saw rides in a truck bed or an ATV rack, measure your space against the Makita listed dimensions and treat the Milwaukee 36 in figure as box size until the listing says otherwise. Both Makita listings describe a brushless direct-drive motor with no gas, no emissions, no oil mixing and no pull starts, which means no fuel can in the truck and lower noise at the woodpile.

Warranty terms in plain language

The two Makita examples state a 3-year limited warranty on tool, battery and charger: one clock for the whole kit. The Milwaukee states a 5 yr warranty on material and workmanship, the longest term of the three, which is the clearest reason to pick that side. Keep the paperwork with the saw either way. Note also that the Milwaukee Included Components line names table saws rather than chainsaw parts, and the Makita XCU04PT components line names a 14 in saw against its 16 in title: in both cases the title is the reliable part of the listing.

Shopping the wider field? See our best battery chainsaws for homeowners.

Three examples

How we scored them

Each example is scored on performance, build, value, safety and warranty, using only what the listing publishes.

Scores run from 9.2 to 9.8: each product’s point total is placed on that range, so more points always means a higher score.

Around the Woodpile

• The Makita examples run on the 18V LXT platform; the XCU04PT1 ships four 5.0Ah batteries, so plan charging around the batteries you own.
• Both Makita examples state tool-less chain adjustment; check tension before each cutting session.
• No example here states a chain brake, so treat the XCU04PT lock-off lever as a backup, not a brake: wear chaps, a helmet with face screen and hearing protection, gloves and boots, and never cut alone.
• Keep warranty paperwork with the saw: 3-year limited on tool, battery and charger for the Makitas, 5 yr on material and workmanship for the Milwaukee.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, a Makita or Milwaukee chainsaw?

Neither in general. The Makita listings state more specs: 36V, 5.0Ah batteries, 3,940 FPM and tool-less adjustment. The Milwaukee listing states a 16 in bar and a 5 yr warranty but little else.

Are these gas or battery saws?

All three examples are battery powered. The Makitas run 36V from two 18V LXT batteries; the Milwaukee battery details are not stated.

Do any of these have a chain brake?

No. None of the three listings states a chain brake or a low-kickback chain. The Makita XCU04PT states a lock-off lever and an LED auto power-off.

What bar length do these saws have?

16 in on all three examples.

What warranty do they carry?

3-year limited on tool, battery and charger for both Makita examples; 5 yr on material and workmanship for the Milwaukee.

Related guides

See the chainsaw hub, the best 16 inch chainsaws and the best battery chainsaws for homeowners.